Save on your stay—reserve directly with us
For vacation rental owners, an open calendar can be uncomfortable.
When upcoming dates remain available, the natural reaction is often to lower the nightly rate. After all, an occupied night at a lower price may seem better than an empty one.
But good vacation rental revenue management is more complicated than simply maximizing occupancy. Recent short-term rental data provides a useful reminder: more booked nights do not necessarily mean better performance—and fewer booked nights do not necessarily mean something is wrong.
In many cases, protecting the right nightly rate can produce better results than aggressively discounting a property simply to fill the calendar.
Recent 2026 data from KeyData, reported by The Host Report, shows encouraging signs for the U.S. short-term rental market.
As of early August, September occupancy was pacing 13% ahead of the same point last year, while nightly rates were 11% higher year over year.
That represents a meaningful change from 2025, when late-summer booking pace was considerably softer.
But perhaps the more interesting story is how vacation rentals are generating revenue.
Across seven of the eight U.S. regions tracked by KeyData, average nightly rates increased during the second quarter. In several regions, occupancy was flat or even slightly lower than the previous year, yet revenue per available rental night still increased substantially.
For example, the Mid-Atlantic reportedly saw essentially flat occupancy while nightly rates and RevPAR increased approximately 12%. The Midwest and New England each experienced slightly lower occupancy but still generated approximately 10% RevPAR growth, supported by higher nightly rates.
These are national and regional figures, not Texas Hill Country-specific performance data. But they illustrate an important revenue-management principle for vacation rental owners everywhere:
Occupancy is only one part of the equation.
It is easy to view 100% occupancy as the ultimate measure of success.
In reality, extremely high occupancy can sometimes be a sign that a property is priced too low.
Consider a simplified example.
Property A books 24 nights at an average nightly rate of $250, generating $6,000 in gross nightly revenue.
Property B books only 20 nights but maintains an average nightly rate of $325, generating $6,500.
Property B has noticeably lower occupancy—but produces more revenue.
It also has four fewer turnovers or occupied nights creating wear on the property, depending on the reservation pattern.
This is why professional vacation rental management should focus on the relationship between occupancy, average daily rate (ADR), RevPAR, booking pace and total revenue, rather than optimizing any one metric in isolation.
Another important consideration is when guests are booking.
Seeing open dates several weeks in advance doesn’t necessarily mean those dates won’t sell.
Booking windows vary significantly based on season, property type, destination, day of the week and traveler behavior. Some periods naturally book much closer to arrival than others.
The September 2026 KeyData numbers provide a good example. At the time of the report, only about 13% of September inventory was booked. On its own, that might sound concerning.
But September was still pacing significantly ahead of where it had been at the same point in 2025.
That distinction matters.
A calendar can look relatively empty while still performing exactly as expected—or even outperforming the prior year—based on historical booking patterns.
This is why reacting to an open calendar without considering booking pace can lead to unnecessary discounting.
There are certainly times when adjusting rates downward makes sense.
If a property’s booking pace is materially behind comparable properties, a high-demand weekend remains unexpectedly open close to arrival, or market conditions have changed, strategic rate adjustments can help capture demand.
The problem is treating price reductions as the automatic solution whenever occupancy looks lower than expected.
Lowering prices too early can create several problems.
First, you may sell nights cheaply that would have booked later at a higher rate.
Second, once a desirable date is sold, there is no opportunity to recover that lost rate.
Third, consistently competing primarily on price can weaken the property’s overall revenue potential.
And finally, lower nightly rates can increase occupancy without necessarily producing enough incremental revenue to justify the additional turnovers, utilities, consumables and wear associated with those stays.
The objective should therefore be the right occupancy at the right rate—not occupancy at any cost.
There is another important part of the current market environment.
According to The Host Report’s analysis of the KeyData findings, guests are still booking and paying higher nightly rates than they were a year ago. At the same time, more vacation rental inventory is competing for those travelers.
That changes the challenge for owners.
In a market with growing supply, simply having a vacation rental available isn’t enough. Properties need to compete effectively for demand.
Pricing is part of that equation, but so are:
A well-positioned property can command a stronger nightly rate because guests see a reason to choose it.
A property that isn’t competitive may struggle even after lowering its price.
The same KeyData report also provides an interesting look at where guests are booking.
Airbnb accounted for approximately 51% of U.S. reservations during the second quarter of 2026, compared with 47% a year earlier. Its share of revenue also increased.
Direct bookings moved in the opposite direction, representing approximately 21% of reservations and 29% of revenue.
That difference is notable.
Although direct reservations represented only about one-fifth of bookings, they generated nearly one-third of revenue, suggesting that direct reservations tend to carry greater value per booking.
For professional managers, this reinforces the importance of both strong OTA performance and developing a direct booking channel over time.
Owners benefit when their property isn’t dependent on only one source of demand.
At Hearth & Haven Vacation Rentals, we don’t evaluate a property’s performance based solely on how many nights are occupied.
We look at the broader picture.
That includes booking pace, nightly rates, occupancy, revenue, reservation value, seasonality and how the property is performing relative to the surrounding market.
Sometimes the correct strategy is to reduce a rate to capture incremental demand.
Other times, the better decision is to remain patient and protect the rate.
And during particularly strong demand periods, rates may need to move higher.
Revenue management is ultimately about continuously balancing those factors rather than relying on a single static nightly price or attempting to keep every night occupied.
National short-term rental data cannot tell us exactly what will happen in Wimberley, Dripping Springs, Canyon Lake, Blanco or another individual Hill Country market.
Vacation rental performance is highly local, and even two properties within the same community can perform differently based on their location, amenities, size, quality and target guest.
But the broader 2026 data reinforces an important lesson.
Don’t judge your vacation rental solely by how full the calendar looks.
An open calendar isn’t automatically evidence of poor performance, just as a completely booked calendar isn’t automatically evidence of great revenue management.
The better questions are:
Are bookings arriving at the expected pace?
Is the property maintaining a competitive nightly rate?
How does performance compare with the market?
Are high-demand dates being priced appropriately?
And, ultimately, is the property generating the revenue it should?
Those questions provide a much better picture of vacation rental performance than occupancy alone.
For Texas Hill Country owners, particularly in an increasingly competitive short-term rental environment, thoughtful pricing and revenue management can make the difference between simply filling nights and maximizing the long-term earning potential of the property.
Wondering what your home could make as a vacation rental? Whether you’re a homeowner exploring short-term rental income, an investor analyzing returns, or a real estate agent advising clients, our expert team is here to help.
Request a Free Rental Evaluation
